Bruce Perens is a noted Open-Source advocate, former employee of Pixar Animation, compelling writer, and noted programmer. He spoke a few years ago at the annual convention for the Utah State University Free Software and Linux User’s Group. Well, OK, calling it a convention when it only involved a few dozen people is a bit of a stretch.
Anyway, I was impressed by his ideas, though he’s definitely a better writer than presenter. In person, he’s actually a bit… what’s the best description… non-charismatic. But he’s been a seminal influence in the Free and Open-Source software communities, and his opinions have a great deal of respect for being on-target. Over the last few years, it seems his attention has been largely focussed on the legal issues related to free software, and broadening more and more into over-arching issues of freedom in the U.S. and abroad. He released the piece below in the early-morning hours today. Do you think he’s right?
Bruce Perens is a noted Open-Source advocate, former employee of Pixar Animation, compelling writer, and noted programmer. He spoke a few years ago at the annual convention for the Utah State University Free Software and Linux User’s Group. Well, OK, calling it a convention when it only involved a few dozen people is a bit of a stretch.
Anyway, I was impressed by his ideas, though he’s definitely a better writer than presenter. In person, he’s actually a bit… what’s the best description… non-charismatic. But he’s been a seminal influence in the Free and Open-Source software communities, and his opinions have a great deal of respect for being on-target. Over the last few years, it seems his attention has been largely focussed on the legal issues related to free software, and broadening more and more into over-arching issues of freedom in the U.S. and abroad. He released the piece below in the early-morning hours today. Do you think he’s right?
Why our Boys Tortured and Murdered Prisoners
Why Our Boys Tortured and Murdered Prisoners
Bruce Perens <bruce@perens.com>
American GIs have tortured and murdered prisoners in Iraq. How could Americans have done this? Because we showed our GIs, by our example, that the rules have changed, that this isn’t the America they knew.
We started by showing them their votes wouldn’t be counted. Problems with ballots in Florida, the state governed by Mr. Bush’s brother, were severe enough to put in doubt which candidate won the election. Studies commissioned by two different newspapers concluded that Mr. Gore should have been declared the winner.
We showed them that our courts were biased. When the Supreme Court had to rule upon the failed election, the vote of the judges was divided upon political party lines.
We showed them that they’d lay their lives down for a lie. Saddam Hussein was a monster. But the weapons of mass destruction that Mr. Bush used to justify the invasion of Iraq still haven’t been found. And there doesn’t seem to be any connection between Iraq and 9/11. Ex Secretary of the Treasury Paul O’Neill reports that Bush planned the Iraq war before 9/11 and the election.
We showed them that our leaders embrace our enemies. George Bush Senior’s Carlyle Group handled the bin Laden family’s investments. Days after 9/11, while U.S. airspace was still closed to regular citizens, private jets sanctioned by the Bush administration evacuated 140 high-ranking Saudi Arabians, including the bin Laden family, from the United States. In 1983, while the U.S. was still assisting the dictator, Donald Rumsfeld was photographed shaking hands with Saadam Hussein.
We showed them that the White House was run for private financial gain. Vice President Cheney’s Haliburton Company was made the prime contractor for the tremendous project to rehabilitate Iraq. Mr. Bush didn’t even want to put this contract out for competitive bid. Oilman Bush maintained close connections with the fraudulent Enron executives and allowed them to directly set American energy policy.
We showed them that separation of church and state did not exist. The ban on stem-cell research, the ban on partial-birth abortion when the mother’s health would be at risk from continuation of the pregnancy, and the furor over same-sex marriage has shown that many states and the federal government still allow religion to drive civil law.
We showed them that America had become intolerant, and that our priorities were not with our soldiers in Iraq. While our boys were dying in Iraq and the torture had already started, we preferred to concern ourselves with a fit of national prudery over the exposure of Janet Jackson’s breast on television.
We showed them that civil liberties had been erased. The draconian PATRIOT act allows Americans to be jailed without any charges, without the right to confront witnesses against them, and they can be kept in jail indefinitely without a trail. It legalizes search and seizure without probable cause, denies the accused’s right to legal counsel, and restricts the right to free speech.
We Americans showed our boys that all of the things we held sacred about The Land of The Free were dead. Should it then have been any surprise that, following our example, their actions would not be unlike those of Nazi death-camp guards?
Mr. Bush is responsible. It is the social changes of the Bush administration, not Mr. Rumsfeld’s supervision of the Armed Forces, that set the context for the torture and murders.
We can prevent more torture and murder by showing our boys that America is not a lie. To do so, we must reverse the damage that Mr. Bush has done to our nation. The first step upon that path is to vote him out of office.
Bruce Perens
The master version of this editorial is at http://perens.com/Articles/WhyOurBoys.html Please check that location for the most recent version.
You may re-publish this editorial. You may excerpt it, reformat it and translate it as necessary for your presentation. You may not edit it to deliberately misrepresent my opinion. Most recent edit date: Mon May 10 14:31:20 UTC 2004