Well, it made national and local news: Child Pornography Sting: Task Force Raids Homes In Salt Lake Valley.
The only thing that made me want to blog about this is the bit of a clip of an interview with — if I understand correctly — our local Attorney General, Mark Shurtleff, with something along these lines:
We were able to track down the, uh, suspects through a months-long intensive effort to locate them using their IP addresses. That is, their Internet Provider address…
I’m certain I didn’t get the quote exactly right because I just heard it on the radio twice in the same day. But it bugged me because he took the time to explain what an IP address was… AND DID IT WRONG!
It’s “Internet Protocol” address, you clueless baboon.
Yeah, look, OK, I understand he’s not a techie. But he’s on the phone doing interviews claiming to have helped track these folks down, and barely has the slightest idea what he’s talking about. What he should have done was refer the reporter to someone competent.
The real problem here lies, however, in what calling this an “Internet Provider” address implies. It implies an attitude by law enforcement that these addresses must be given to you by an Internet Provider of some sort… a commercial entity that leases you an IP address temporarily.
It completely ignores the fact that Class C address space was freely given out to individuals prior to 1993. My friend John owns a netblock. He doesn’t use it, as he hasn’t found a provider willing to route the netblock for a reasonable fee, but he owns it free-and-clear. And in the up-and-coming IPv6 space — a new standard which should solve the “running out of addresses” problem for a millenia or two — IP addresses will be permanently assigned to many devices, following them throughout their lives and expiring when they finally die or are retired.
Anyway, you can have an IP address without having an “Internet Provider” to speak of. You can set up a private one in your home. You can run one over a VPN. Your provider doesn’t give them to you, and other than the DHCP records provided by a few willing and compliant ISPs, they can be as ephemeral and temporary as your mood, or as permanent as your favorite jacket. I have owned, cared for, and managed Internet Protocol addresses for virtually all of my adult life. No “Internet Provider” need be responsible for them.
I started an entry covering the whole child pornography weirdness in the USA, then left off because I think that’s a topic all on its own…