Note: Due to the size of this thread and the difficulty navigating it, I have closed it to new comment entries. Thank you for understanding.
For those of you who are only interested in getting to the moral of the story, there are two:
- Be extremely cautious and conservative buying stuff off of eBay
- Anything which sounds to good to be true probably is.
The other day, my wife’s passing hand, combined with some static buildup, managed to shock my aging, decrepit laptop enough that the network card and PCMCIA slot failed to work for the next hour and a half. Eventually, they “came back” on their own (several reboots later), after a great deal of monkeying, shaking, powering-off, unplugging, removing batteries, and general hair-pulling and curse-slinging.
I realized then that my old, reliable Sony Vaio PCG-Z505SX had seen better days. It never has really been a “desktop replacement”, but much more a “desktop adjunct”. The thing I really like about it is the size. It’s small — only a 12″ screen — and the keys are in intuitive locations. It has a positive “feel” why you type on the keyboard, and that’s 90% of what I do: typing. Well, if you exclude mousing.
When I want to play games, I go sit in front of my big desktop computer and play. I also use that same workstation to record music, and frequently I’ve found that drivers or updates which I need to play a given game conflict with what I need to run my digital recording gear. It sucks, but recording wins out over games. I have a few still sitting in their boxes because I found that, in order to run them, I had to upgrade drivers which would then cause my recording rig to not work right. Darn. They remain unplayed.
Anyway, I got laptop-hungry. This laptop broke, and I realized that it was last mass-produced in 1999. That’s a good run for a piece of hardware, and other than having to replace the hard drive a year ago, it’s been really good to me. All good things must end, and I suspect this recent ethernet/PC card failure is the first of many failures to come. Besides, it can only fit 128MB of RAM. I have more RAM than that on the video card of my desktop PC. It does make it a somewhat slow, frustrating experience to use, ameliorated only by the fact that I have it running GNU/Linux, which handles aging, under-sized hardware much more gracefully than Windows XP.
Here’s where the real adventure begins. I spent some time early this morning, over lunch, and this evening investigating laptop options. I checked out the most recent models, read a bunch of reviews, and decided what kinds of features I wanted. Initially, I really wanted an Apple PowerBook, but I abandoned that plan. As much as I love my Mac upstairs, I realized that I could replace my 4-year-old recording rig with a new laptop. I don’t want to re-invest the money in a Mac-based recording rig, really. It was too expensive, and took too much time to build up, for me to want to do it all over again on a different software platform.
Besides, there’s that whole learning-curve thing. I’m comfortable with Cakewalk Sonar. I really don’t want to learn ProTools if I can avoid it.
I found some great deals on eBay. Being somewhat naive about these things, I followed the instruction on the posting which said, “I have a buy-it-now price for this auction; contact me at b_blancoo0@yahoo.com for the price”.
I did so. Here’s the e-mail exchange. I quickly became very leery. See if you can spot what’s wrong with his responses…
From: Me To: b_blancoo0@yahoo.com Date: Tue, 22 Mar 2005 19:27:30 -0700 Subject: Buy it now on Alienware Area51m 3.2GHz P4 1GB RAM 60GB HD
You mentioned to write you for “buy it now” pricing on the Alienware Area51m 3.2GHz P4 1GB RAM 60GB HD . What is that?
Thanks,
Matthew P. Barnson
From: Miser <b_blancoo0@yahoo.com> To: Me Date: Tue, 22 Mar 2005 18:42:00 -0800 (PST) Subject: Re: Buy it now on Alienware Area51m 3.2GHz P4 1GB RAM 60GB HD
the buy it now price is$825 with shipping included reply me asap!
From: Me To: Miser <b_blancoo0@yahoo.com> Date: Tue, 22 Mar 2005 20:19:37 -0700 Subject: Re: Buy it now on Alienware Area51m 3.2GHz P4 1GB RAM 60GB HD
I apologize for my incredulity, but that seems to be about $1,000 less than competing similar laptops. How do you sell them at such a low price? Is this simply a great deal for the ethically-challenged?
In addition, your eBay account seems to have been suspended due to your request for offline “buy it now” requests. Do you plan to reinstate it? I would feel more comfortable making a purchase knowing that your account is in good standing.
From: Miser <b_blancoo0@yahoo.com> To: Me Date: Tue, 22 Mar 2005 19:26:20 -0800 (PST) Subject: Re: Buy it now on Alienware Area51m 3.2GHz P4 1GB RAM 60GB HD
sir i have a problem with my account and i stop the auctions and ebat will resolv this problem i sell at this price because i need this money for my soon life reply me asap and tell if you make this deal with me
Yep. 100% criminal. Important tip for would-be criminals: if a customer asks why something is such a good deal, telling them the price is good because “i need this money for my soon life” is probably not a good gambit. This would be laughable if it weren’t for the next closed-bid seller whom I contacted regarding the sale of a laptop who was so remarkably similar.
From: Emicrox11@aol.com <Emicrox11@aol.com> To: Me Date: Tue, 22 Mar 2005 22:46:53 EST Subject: Re: Question for item #5567966663 – BRAND NEW ALIENWARE AREA-51M 7700 3.2, WI…
HI First I want to tell you that my laptop are brand new, unopened box all accessories included and also an international warranty . My price is the best you could get: 900USD(not euro), including the shipping and insurance taxes. We will pay them because the package will be delivered from Europe. As delivery service we use UPS2days air service or overnight (with insurance and 15 days return policy), because it’s the faster. And if you will have a quick payment, we must also have a quick delivery. So that’s why we use as a payment method Western Union money transfer, the fastest and also very secure way of sending money. I just open a electronics company here in europe If i will make with you a good deal,you will recommend me ,maybe ,to your friends or to other persons.For me it is very important to have permanent deals on ebay, any negatice deal will not make good to me,That explain the price So, if you agree with my terms I’m sure that we can close the deal as soon as possible. Waiting your quick answer right now, THANK YOU
Another important tip for would-be criminals: Asking people to send money internationally via Western Union is almost a sure tip-off that this is a version of the Spanish Prisoner, a.k.a. the Nigerian Scam. Of course, hundreds of people fall for this every year, to the tune of thousands and possibly millions of dollars…
I did not purchase from either seller. I value my money. Here are my suggestions when you make ebay purchases:
- Check the seller’s history. Not just their feedback rating, because these days so many accounts are getting hijacked, but actually what they have sold, how much they’ve sold it for, what their payment requirements were, etc. For instance, the feedback history on the second seller was great. But all he had ever sold were sporting goods, and he had only ever accepted PayPal. This is a sudden, out-of-character change. Even if it were legit, that sudden of a change would leave me leery.
- No Western Union or Money Orders out of the country. It doesn’t matter how good the deal is, it’s not a good deal when they walk away with your $1000 and you have nothing to show for it.
- As much as I hate to say it, check their grammatical habits. “Nigerian Scammers” have a peculiar writing style. It’s an immediate red-flag to a potential ripoff. On the other hand, someone being smooth and well-spoken is no guarantee of truthfulness. That’s why con artists do so well in this country, too.
I despise criminals. My greatest concern is simply that I’ve given these scammers my real-life email address, and I’m really not that tough to locate. Ahh, well, there’s no such thing as privacy anyways.
— Matthew P. Barnson – – – – Thought for the moment: Of course there’s no reason for it, it’s just our policy.