Let’s get the big ones out of the way.
Is the movie all the positive reviews say it is.. the best ever made.. or even better than Braveheart?
As a film, no. As a matter of fact, it is a film with flaws, it makes a couple odd decisions, and has at least one shot that I considered out there.
Okay, then, is it as bad as the negative reviews have said.. Boring, Fetishist, or just plain Bad?
By no means. As a film, it is quite good – on about the level of “The Patriot” or “Amistad”.. but not quite “Schindler’s List” or “Braveheart”. As a film, it is comparable to “Return of the King” in that it makes some mistakes, overkills some moments, but is still tear rendering in parts, and in its entirity, equals more than the sum of its parts.
Let’s get the big ones out of the way.
Is the movie all the positive reviews say it is.. the best ever made.. or even better than Braveheart? As a film, no. As a matter of fact, it is a film with flaws, it makes a couple odd decisions, and has at least one shot that I considered out there.
Okay, then, is it as bad as the negative reviews have said.. Boring, Fetishist, or just plain Bad? By no means. As a film, it is quite good – on about the level of “The Patriot” or “Amistad”.. but not quite “Schindler’s List” or “Braveheart”. As a film, it is comparable to “Return of the King” in that it makes some mistakes, overkills some moments, but is still tear rendering in parts, and in its entirity, equals more than the sum of its parts.
Okay then again.. Is the Film Anti Semetic? No.. but if I were Jewish, and looking for it, I would notice that Caphius, the Jewish High Priest, and the Crowd of his supporters, are really given the Black hat in this film. They are villians in the movie.. almost Mustache twirling, while Pilate is let off easy. That being said, every hero in the film is Jewish, the Roman Guards are the most brutal, and the only character in the film called “Jew” to his face, is a non-follower of Jesus who willingly puts his life on the line to try to save Christ. The movie is true to the Gospels, and does leave out some inflammatory moments, in order to be more friendly.
Is the film too Violent? No, but it is QUITE violent, in three points.. and, of course, Christ is bloody most of the film. That being said, Gibson pulls away a LOT, gives us a LOT of breaks, a LOT of out of focus shots and reaction shots. It is very like the scene where William Wallace is tortured in “Braveheart”, but three times, with a bit more blood. It doesn’t compare to “Kill Bill”, “Natural Born Killers”, “Freddy Vs. Jason”, or any of those. It is not for the squeamish, but it is an appropriate level of violence for a Rated R film.
Well, then, Justin, what DID you think, in your own words… AS A MOVIE: Well shot, well acted, well scored, well edited, well written film that makes mistakes, and runs the risk of alienating a Jewish audience. A Brilliant performance by Jim Caveziel as Jesus, and Notable performances by Mary, Satan, and Mary Magdelene. Much like watching Frodo bounce on the bed in “Return of the King”, there are oments I wish I could cut out or shorten, not because of brutality, but because they don’t belong or they are redundant.
3 and a Half Stars
PERSONALLY: I don’t think Gibson was trying to make a great movie.. and that is important. This is supposed to be a tool to slap complacent Christians a bit.. and say “Guess what.. it wasn’t a little mocking, and up he goes”. This movie made me cry twice (I don’t often really cry in movies), and made me relate to my faith in a closer way than I have in a while. There are things I believe, that I always have, that now, I better understand. It is harder to be complacent now.
As a message, it did more for me than most church services I have attended, and made me reexamine at times.. and at times had very visceral emotional moments for me. I believe that this man was put not put on a cross, but went there willingly, and by doing so, I have benefitted. Once the emotional mountaintop experience leaves (I dont put much stock in that anyway) I will be left with the contemplation, and that will stick with me long after I am done emotionalizing.
I am faced with a real man instead of just an icon, going through real stuff, instead of just ignorable words, that really really sucked to go through.. and he could have chosen not to.. and suddenly it is a LOT less about “hell”, or this whole “God will get you” mentality that gets criticized so often… its about gratitude, end of sermon.
Justin, WHO will like “Passion of the Christ” most believers will. most people on the fence will. Fans of artsy cinema will. Gibson (as a director) fans will. People with strong stomachs exploring Christianity will.
WHO WONT? Many Jews, Many atheists, People who have hosility toward Christianity and if you have a kid under 14, keep them away. People unaccustomed to violence will be turned off and find it gratuitous.. those who are used to it a bit more will handle it well.
Okay, lads and ladies.. what are your responses..